Archive for December, 2005

More Engineering Deficit Mythology

In the ongoing debate over the impact of offshoring on the American workforce, BusinessWeek notes a new study arguing that the engineering deficit may be a myth. This new study by Vivek Wadhwa of Duke University points out that “Indian and Chinese numbers [of engineers] can be wildly exaggerated, while America’s are understated.” The reason for these discrepancies in data reporting stems from the fact that India and China use different, looser criteria than the United States in defining what an engineer is, giving them artificially inflated numbers. In fact, when applying a consistent definition of an engineer, the U.S. graduates more engineers per capita than either of these two rising superpowers.

While optimistic, this finding does not mean that the engineering deficit is just a myth. As cited in an earlier Engineering &… post, the number of engineering degrees granted in the United States has risen, while companies are having an increasingly difficult time filling their more specialized technical positions. One reason for this, as BusinessWeek points out, is that

Many of the U.S. engineers who are getting displaced lack the more demanding skills required by American tech companies today. Because routine tasks can be done more cheaply offshore, many executives say, they need U.S. engineers who can rapidly move on to next-generation technologies, work well with customers, and manage R&D teams.

The fact that only these highly demanding positions remain open to the American workforce discourages many from entering the engineering field. Unless engineers graduate with the necessary skills to enter a workforce that is increasingly limited by offshoring, America’s engineering deficit will only continue to grow.


Faith in Engineering

Engineering and science have become increasingly at odds with religion, or so it seems. On Tuesday, John E. Jones III, a federal judge, ruled that it was unconstitutional for a Pennsylvania school district to teach intelligent design as an alternative to evolution in high school biology courses, citing that it is a religious viewpoint that promotes “a particular version of Christianity.” He argues that “To be sure, Darwin’s theory of evolution is imperfect. However, the fact that a scientific theory cannot yet render an explanation on every point should not be used as a pretext to thrust an untestable alternative hypothesis grounded in religion into the science classroom or to misrepresent well-established scientific propositions.” The entire ruling can be found here.

While people may not settle the heated debate over Intelligent Design versus Darwinism any time soon, there are those who find quite meaningful and peaceful ways of incorporating faith into science and engineering. Armed with a master’s degree in divinity and Ph.D. in electrical engineering, W. Kent Fuchs, Dean of Cornell University’s College of Engineering has found many similarities between his two fields of study. Both engineering and religion, he says, are designed to provide assistance, albeit in very different ways- one tangible and the other spiritual. To improve the relation between the two subjects, he suggests that “we have lost track of the human component of what we do. We have focused on the technology, not on the good that it can do.” Read more about Fuchs’ philosophy on the links between engineering and religion in PRISM.


Holiday Cookies the Way Engineers Intended


Chocolate Chip Cookies
Ingredients:

1. 532.35 cm3 gluten
2. 4.9 cm3 NaHCO3
3. 4.9 cm3 refined halite
4. 236.6 cm3 partially hydrogenated tallow triglyceride
5. 177.45 cm3 crystalline C12H22O11
6. 177.45 cm3 unrefined C12H22O11
7. 4.9 cm3 methyl ether of protocatechuic aldehyde
8. Two calcium carbonate-encapsulated avian albumen-coated protein
9. 473.2 cm3 theobroma cacao
10. 236.6 cm3 de-encapsulated legume meats (sieve size #10)

To a 2 liter jacketed round reactor vessel (reactor #1) with an overall heat transfer coefficient of about 100 Btu/°F-ft2-hr, add ingredients one, two and three with constant agitation. In a second 2 liter reactor vessel with a radial flow impeller operating at 100 rpm, add ingredients four, five, six, and seven until the mixture is homogenous.

To reactor #2, add ingredient eight, followed by three equal volumes of the homogenous mixture in reactor #1. Additionally, add ingredient nine and ten slowly, with constant agitation. Care must be taken at this point in the reaction to control any temperature rise that may be the result of an exothermic reaction.

Using a screw extrude attached to a #4 nodulizer, place the mixture piece-meal on a 316SS sheet (300 x 600 mm). Heat in a 460°K oven for a period of time that is in agreement with Frank & Johnston’s first order rate expression (see JACOS, 21, 55), or until golden brown. Once the reaction is complete, place the sheet on a 25°C heat-transfer table, allowing the product to come to equilibrium.


Immigration Reform, But At What Cost?

The U.S. may be running its hopes of improved engineering research into the ground. Resurrected in part by the recent November elections and President Bush’s approval of an increased budget for immigration enforcement, immigration policy has come to the foreground of many political debates. Additionally, in light of the fact that Arizona and New Mexico have both declared states of emergency, policies have been proposed that would even further restrict immigration. Due to President Bush’s renewed fervor on this subject, it seems likely that there will be a comprehensive immigration bill in 2006 that will further limit the number of visas issued by the U.S.

However, it seems unfair to apply these new restrictions to foreigners with graduate degrees seeking to perform research in hi-tech areas, especially when those areas are already suffering. Between 2003 and 2004, applications from abroad to U.S. graduate engineering schools declined by 36%. This is not a statistic to be taken lightly. Without a steady stream of foreign minds, U.S. research and development will surely suffer as these bright minds turn to our competitors for work. As a counter to this trend, two innovation bills based on the Council on Competitiveness’ and National Academies’ recommendations should come up in senate within the next month. These bills aim to increase the number of visas available to highly skilled workers. But this is only part of the solution; in addition to visa complications and hassles, highly skilled workers face a less than receptive work environment once they do secure a visa, discouraging many from even applying to work in the U.S. Read more about the shortage of foreign minds in the U.S. and some of the actions engineers are taking to make life easier for those acculturating to the U.S. hi-tech sector in PRISM.


Engineering a Cure

AIDS RibbonIn honor of World AIDS Day, ASEE would like to extend its condolences to the millions of people who are afflicted by this horrible and devastating epidemic. Issues of funding have long plagued the end to this disease. However, some progress has been made since the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation identified the 14 Grand Challenges in Global health. One of the top priorities in these challenges involves engineering an HIV vaccine that is easily replicated and then distributed to the areas of the world that need it the most. One of the major roadblocks in developing a vaccine that meets these criteria, however, is making the scale of production economically feasible while still maintaining quality. According to the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative,

As product development moves forward, a key question for developers is whether a promising vaccine concept can actually be produced effectively and affordably as a candidate vaccine. The design and implementation of a vaccine manufacturing process – known as “bioprocess development” – requires a wide range of chemical and mechanical engineering, biochemistry, and microbiology skills….

To meet regulatory requirements, a developer must devise a process that can produce vaccine in the relatively small amounts needed for trials and also develop a process that can produce the amounts needed for large-scale use. But increasing the scale of a manufacturing process is not just a matter of a larger supply of ingredients and bigger equipment. Many manufacturing processes vary in non-linear ways as scale increases and as a result, technical processes that work in small volumes in a laboratory may not work at large scales….

At large scales of production, small differences in yields or manufacturing efficiency can have a major impact on costs. Getting the process right for a particular vaccine is crucial to its profitability for developers and its affordability for users.

Click here for the full brief on the obstacles engineers and scientists face in developing an HIV vaccine.


Search on this site:


Categories:

Links:

Tags:

appropriate technology ASEE career Civil Engineering Computer Science design Diversity Do-it-yourself economics Education Electrical Engineering energy engineering engineering education engineering projects engineers Engineers Without Boarders Environmental Engineering Envirotech fellowships funding Future green engineering How Things Work Innovation internet k-12 making a difference managing engineers materials engineering mechanical engineering NSF project management Research robots science science literacy Society technology The Economy The National Interest university webcast women workplace
  • Archives: